Episode 21: Early Germanic Words

We look at the first inscription found in a Germanic language and the vocabulary of the early Germanic tribes. The impact of Grimm’s Law on the early Germanic language is examined.

5 thoughts on “Episode 21: Early Germanic Words

  1. Hi, I discovered your podcast recently and I’m binge-listening to it. It’s amazingly interesting and well-made!!
    I found this episode to be one of the more interesting ones, and I have two questions. First, why do we assume that the Germanic tribes spoke pretty much the same Germanic language? Couldn’t there have been mutually unintelligible Germanic languages and one language won out over time and evolved into the modern languages? And second, I was intrigued about the pre-IE people in Scandinavia. Do you have references so I can read more about it? Again thanks a lot for your amazing podcast

    • Hi Habib,

      I think the answer to your first question is really semantic. By definition, the ‘Germanic’ tribes were those who spoke Germanic languages. So technically speaking, all of the Germanic tribes spoke a Germanic language. Of course, there were other people who spoke non-Germanic languages as well. Some of those people spoke Celtic languages, and some probably spoke languages that have long-since disappeared. Since the Germanic languages have a lot of non-PIE words in their core vocabulary, one or more of those non-Germanic tribes likely mixed with the Germanic-speaking tribes very early on. Unfortunately, very little is known about them. In his book, “Our Magnificent Bastard Tongue,” John McWhorter suggests that this unknown tribe spoke a Semitic language and were descendants of the Phoenicians. Of course, there is no proof at this time.

      For additional research about the Pre-PIE people of northern Europe, I would recommend any resource that discusses the Corded Ware people. One of my primary sources was the Oxford Illustrated History of Prehistoric Europe by Barry Cunliffe.

  2. Regarding the possible mix of early Scandinavians with non Indo European speakers: I wonder whether geneticists will be able to identify it using the latest ancestral DNA research techniques.

    • I am not aware of any recent DNA studies that have looked at this issue, but it is definitely a fascinating topic that deserves more research. If I come across any studies related to this issue, I will provide an update in the podcast.

  3. I know DNA is not your field of expertise, but I recently discovered that 1% of my DNA is Finnish and 12% Scandinavian. It makes me curious about the original inhabitants of Finland might be that elusive non-IndoEuropean people.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.